Donate today!
view counter

April 2012 Vol. 19. No. 5 Focus on Engaging Curriculum

Other news & features

More schools to become Renaissance charters

By by Benjamin Herold on Mar 30, 2012 03:34 PM

Undeterred by a bleak budget picture, District officials announced in February that four more low-performing traditional public schools will be converted to charters as part of the Renaissance Schools initiative.

The four schools – Cleveland Elementary, Creighton Elementary, H.R. Edmunds Elementary, and Jones Middle – currently serve more than 3,000 students. Although the schools will be turned over to outside managers, they will remain neighborhood schools, continuing to serve currently enrolled students and those who live in the surrounding community.

Officials described the expansion of the Renaissance initiative as a key component of the District's formal pledge to replace or transform 50,000 seats in low-performing schools over the next five years.

"By continuing this initiative, the District underlines its commitment to The Philadelphia Great Schools Compact," said a press release announcing the news.

Due to financial constraints, the District said it would do no District-run turnarounds this year, halting the expansion of Promise Academies.

Officials projected that converting the four schools to charters next year will cost between $2.5 and $3 million. But they have no estimate of an annual cost to the District associated with maintaining the current 13 Renaissance charters.

Teachers' union President Jerry Jordan blasted the continued expenditures on charter conversions even as the District slashes staff and services at traditional public schools.

"I think it's nothing short of outrageous," he said, noting that schools were not receiving adequate supports that could help them improve on their own. "Teachers really do believe they are being blamed wrongly."

District officials said the factors used to identify new Renaissance Schools included histories of poor academic performance, school climate, feeder patterns, and neighborhood characteristics.

Jordan, however, said the District has done a "terrible job" of explaining why these four schools were chosen. Cleveland, for instance, was not considered low-achieving enough to be an Empowerment School, although it was on the "Renaissance Alert" list.

Jordan suggested that Cleveland is on the list because the District's largest Renaissance operator, Mastery Charter, wants to run it. It is a feeder school for Mastery-Simon Gratz High.

The District has acknowledged that interest from prospective Renaissance operators was a factor in selecting the schools this year.

And for the first time, the "prequalified" Renaissance operators were allowed to pick which schools they want to compete for. Mastery is seeking only Cleveland.

Jones Middle has just two suitors: American Paradigm, a Renaissance newcomer with no turnaround experience, and Mosaica Turnaround Partners, the only for-profit operator among this year's prospective providers.

As in past years, School Advisory Councils consisting of parents and community members will have a say in choosing who manages each school.

The six-week "Renaissance match" process started in March, when SACs began reviewing provider proposals and hosting forums where prospective turnaround teams made their case.

Renaissance newcomer String Theory Schools, a spinoff of the Performing Arts Charter in South Philadelphia, is competing for Creighton and Edmunds.

String Theory Executive Director Angela Corosanite said she expects parents to be excited about its approach, which gives performing arts opportunities to all students.

"I think our model works everywhere," said Corosanite. "Happy children want to learn."

Stakeholders from at least one targeted school are opposing charter conversion. Parents and staff from Creighton Elementary rallied outside their school on March 13 in protest.

"We are already correcting ourselves," said Creighton Home and School President Delores Waters.

Decisions in April

SACs are expected to make non-binding recommendations on their preferred providers by mid-April. District Chief Recovery Officer Thomas Knudsen will then make a formal proposal to the School Reform Commission, which is expected to vote on the final matches April 19.

Despite past debacles at West Philadelphia and Martin Luther King high schools, District Deputy for Strategic Initiatives Thomas Darden expressed faith in the integrity of the matching process.

"When SACs are given full autonomy to evaluate turnaround teams and participate fully, they make good decisions for schools and communities," he said.

Thomas DardenWhile there will be no new Promise Academies next fall, Darden said that the District "remains committed" to operate the model at the existing nine schools. Any expansion must wait until the District's academic reorganization is completed, he added.

In February, local nonprofit Research for Action released a report showing that in the first year of the initiative, both Renaissance charters and Promise Academies showed statistically significant student achievement gains that outpaced those of comparable K-8 schools.

"These findings suggest that the Renaissance Schools initiative is having a strong, positive effect on K-8 students' schools," said RFA Executive Director Kate Shaw.

The study found no appreciable differences among the four first-year Renaissance providers nor between the charter conversions and the Promise Academies.

But the rigor and validity of the study has been questioned by the Institute of Education Sciences, the research arm of the U.S. Department of Education.

SRC invites input

On March 12, the SRC hosted a "strategy, policy and priority" meeting, inviting input on the Renaissance initiative.

Several parents connected with Renaissance charters operated by Mastery spoke of the urgency of continuing the turnaround effort.

"Our children do not have years to waste in low-performing schools," said George Tilghmann, SAC president at Mastery-Harrity.

But some advocates questioned the District's commitment to traditional public schools.

"We as teachers feel really shut out," said retired teacher and Notebook blogger Ron Whitehorne. "All the options are either charter schools or a top-down, scripted model."

About the Author

Contact Notebook/NewsWorks reporter Benjamin Herold at

Comments (2)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 10, 2012 8:24 pm

Nobody with an ounce of sense believes there's a budget crisis. Nazi Corbett is simply starving the real schools and giving money to his charter buddies. It's just a corporate bullrush and anybody with eyes should be able to see it clearly. If fellow Nazi Scott Walker is booted out in Wisconsin, we will begin to see some sanity return to the education process.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 18, 2012 2:24 am

Jerry Jordan is the worst union president at the worst possible time. His inaction on almost all issues, except when in the public eye and he can gain publicity, is the reason the District now and for previous years get away with whatever they want.

The lack of ability on the PFT's part allows the District to play out why they illegally disregard contracts, policies, rules, precedent, past practices, verbal agreements,etc.

Most if not all members of this union sadly are going be without a decent contract or job in the not too distant future as the PFT sits there and continues to act "shocked" by what is going on. However, Jordan and his PFT officers will be retired (since many are at or very close to retirement age now) by then and could careless.

The PFT needs honest,caring,strong leadership which is totally lacking presently.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. We reserve the right to delete or remove any material deemed to be in violation of this rule, and to ban anyone who violates this rule. Please see our "Terms of Usage" for more detail concerning your obligations as a user of this service. Reader comments are limited to 500 words. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

Table of Contents

Read the latest print issue

Philly Ed Feed


Public School Notebook

699 Ranstead St.
Third Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Phone: (215) 839-0082
Fax: (215) 238-2300

© Copyright 2013 The Philadelphia Public School Notebook. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Usage and Privacy Policy