The FeedEditionsJobsDonateJune Event
Philly Education News + Views Independent. Reader-Supported.
Philly Education News + Views
Independent. Reader-Supported




Response to the October 2012 edition article “Painful choices” 

Thank you, Benjamin Herold, for another story told with sensitivity and thoughtfulness. I think Karen Lewis was a good choice to profile because she is what the city wants to attract to be a resident – a young, educated professional raising a family. Her story illustrates the stumbling blocks that aren’t always apparent in the “official” discussions. 

What a loss for her neighborhood public school, though. They could not understand her objections. Where was the school’s Home and School, which should have helped her? Was there a parent ombudsman in place? How about a School Advisory Council? 

This story also illustrates an underlying conflict in class values that is not generally talked about. I am no stranger to the disrespect that was shown to her. There is a real fear of those who are highly educated among a lot of the families that live here, even among many of the teachers and school staff. Just by the way you use English, your abstract values – even if you give generously as Lewis was willing to do in her volunteering – you will be judged as arrogant or imposing, and even “spoiled,” as some of the commenters on the Notebook website stated. 

Best of luck to you, Karen, and your son, Cooper!

Lily Cheng 

The writer is a volunteer parent working with Temple’s Community Music Scholars program and the Central High School Music Association.


Get the Notebook in your inbox

Notes from the news
Weekly newsletter

Recent Articles

Mifflin students protest split-grade classroom plan and get new teacher Journeys to the United States A glossary of terms, resources for English learners How schools teach English amid other lessons Language obstacles can be conquered

Philly public schools, post a pic of staff or students reading the Notebook on our FB page!

The first 40 schools to post a pic and tell us why the Notebook is important will receive 100 of our new water bottles

Click here for info