The FeedEditionsJobsDonateJune Event
Philly Education News + Views Independent. Reader-Supported.
Menu
Menu
Philly Education News + Views
Independent. Reader-Supported

The education of children cannot be uniform

commentary

a

a

a

  • commentary box1

When I asked a diabetic student of mine why her glucose level was so high, she said she'd forgotten to take her insulin that morning. I was aghast. Having a high glucose level is one thing. Forgetting to take the insulin that keeps her healthy and alive was shocking.

I've seen many students like her: asthmatics who don’t take their inhalers on a regular basis, kids who never finish their course of antibiotics, and other students who refuse to follow medical advice.

As a school nurse, I've heard all the excuses: I forgot. The medicine tastes nasty. I lost it. It’s too much work. My cousin stopped taking his pills and he was OK.

Choosing not to take the medication that saves your life or keeps you well seems like counterintuitive behavior. But students often act this way. Kids smoke pot on their way to school despite regularly getting caught. Girls and boys have babies when they are themselves babies. Students refuse to do their classwork or homework, even though they know it will lead to failing.
 
This phenomenon, a kind of failure to act in one's own self-interest, happens in the adult world, too. A friend of mine regularly cuts back on her seizure medication in the hope that she has somehow been miraculously cured of her disorder. My own father would sit with his cigarette lit in one hand, oxygen mask in the other, unwilling to stop smoking but willing to risk blowing up the house.

Human behavior is unpredictable. Organizations that choose not to account in their planning for the vagaries of human behavior will make costly errors.

Take those who believe that streamlining, codifying, and making all procedures and products uniform will somehow make people more “efficient.” In education, this thinking has led to thinking of children, a truly unpredictable group, as “seats” that “perform” on demand.

To these reformers, all teachers have to do is stuff children full of canned programs and employ scripted practices, then voilá, success! Any teacher worth his or her salt will tell you this belief is not only naïve, but also destructive -- because it ignores the other factors that have made the child into what he or she is. Somewhere between the endless drilling of skills and constant filling of test bubbles, the child’s humanity is lost.

What the lesson of raising a family teaches, as any parent will testify, is that children growing up in the same family will be different and perform differently in school. They will peform differently regardless of the fact that they had the same parents, lived in the same house, ate the same food, read the same books, and attended the same schools.

The education of children is a difficult and complex process, because people are difficult and complex. There is no magic bullet, no messiah that can right every educational wrong. There is no program, however cleverly developed and implemented, that will fit the needs of every child. 

The hucksters who would reduce the art of teaching children to a technical set of skills that even the inexperienced can impart are misguided. Children are so much more than empty receptacles waiting to be filled or scores on standardized tests.

Eileen M. DiFranco, R.N., is a certified school nurse who has proudly served the schoolchildren of Philadelphia for 23 years. She is a lifelong resident of Philadelphia.


The opinions expressed are solely those of the author.

Get the Notebook in your inbox

Notes from the news
Weekly newsletter
Promotions

Recent Articles

Parents from across Pa. weigh in on education funding Notes from the news - Sept. 26 Gov. Wolf visits Philly to talk education funding, tout record Notes from the news - Sept. 23 Auditor finds conflicts in spending of cyber charter

Eileen DiFranco

Eileen M. DiFranco, R.N., is a certified school nurse who has proudly served the schoolchildren of Philadelphia for 25 years. She is a lifelong resident of Philadelphia.

The 2016 Notebook Fall Guides are in! Contact the Notebook for bulk copies.

If you rely on the Notebook's Fall Guide, our print issues, and our 24/7 website, become a member today!

Donate